The recent complaints about littering in the Snug Harbor P-Section — commonly also known as the “Camping Section” — has sparked frustration from property owners. Social media posts have focused on loose cups, scattered trash, a toy and the occasional debris left behind by visitors or renters.
But there’s an uncomfortable truth that many people conveniently ignore:
The P-Section was never intended to function as a traditional permanent residential neighborhood.
According to the original concept and SHPOA governing documents, the P-Section was designed primarily for camping and recreational use. Yet over the years, many lots have gradually transformed into what are effectively full-time residences. Some owners live there year-round while simultaneously criticizing the very activity the section was originally created for.
That contradiction is difficult to ignore.
A Camping Section That Attracts Campers
The P-Section naturally attracts short-term visitors, RV owners, weekend campers, boaters, and renters looking for an affordable getaway near the water. With that comes increased traffic, temporary occupancy, and yes — occasionally litter.
Nobody is defending trashing the neighborhood. Everyone should clean up after themselves. Property owners and renters alike should respect the area.
But there’s a difference between legitimate concerns about chronic dumping and outrage over a single loose cup, a child’s toy motorcycle or stray wrapper blowing through after a windy weekend.
Communities lose credibility when every minor issue becomes a public emergency !
Selective Rule Enforcement Helps No One
Many of the loudest complaints are coming from permanent residents in a P-Section where permanent residency was never supposed to become the norm in the first place.
That raises a fair question:
Should people who are themselves violating the spirit — or possibly the letter — of the governing documents be policing others over minor litter issues?
If SHPOA rules matter, then they should matter consistently.
That means:
- Campers and renters should clean up after themselves.
- Property owners should maintain their lots responsibly.
- And permanent residential use in the camping section should not simply be ignored while smaller infractions become the focus of outrage.
Communities thrive when standards are applied evenly, not selectively.
The Real Issue: Respect for the Community
At its core, this debate is less about trash and more about expectations.
Some residents want the P-Section to function like a quiet suburban neighborhood. But the area was established as a camping and recreational section, meaning there will always be a different atmosphere than in strictly residential parts of Snug Harbor.
More visitors.
More turnover.
More activity.
More occasional mess.
That doesn’t mean standards disappear. It means expectations should match reality.
Instead of endless complaints over isolated litter incidents, the community would benefit more from practical solutions:
- More trash receptacles
- Better communication with renters
- Clear cleanup expectations
- Consistent enforcement of all SHPOA rules
Because if the conversation is truly about preserving the integrity of the P-Section, then the rules regarding permanent residency deserve just as much attention as a discarded plastic cup.
In the end, maintaining a healthy community requires balance, fairness, and honesty about what the P-Section was originally meant to be.
About the Author
